I'm not a Katharine hater, really! In fact I posted a comment saying I think she actually had the best song last week--but she also had the worst as well. ^^'

This week she did okay first song, but totally blew her second--I mean that should have been a soft tender song, and she sang it like it was a power ballad--no real emotion or style. Over sang it.

On merits alone? Who else could go home? Elliot was the underdog, and yet he put on performances that showed he meant business. Chris, was well, Chris. Personally his voice annoys me, but he's definitely talented. Taylor did what Taylor does best: entertained (in fun way) with his first song (though I don't think vocally that good), and came back with a strong vocal on the second.

If Katharine does go home, Randy called this competition way back--the guys being the favs.